Workshop on Food Safety of GM Crops, 8-9 August 2004, Bogor, Indonesia

Workshop documents

The Indonesian Agricultural Biotechnology and Genetic Resources Research Agency In Bogor, Indonesia in collaboration with FAO-RAP Project (GCP/RAS/185 JPN) on Capacity Building in Biosafety of GM Crops conducted the National Training Workshop on Food Safety of GM Crops from August 8-9, 2004. A total of 60 stakeholders coming from various places in Indonesia attended the workshop. The participants s were composed of researchers at national research institutes and universities, plant quarantine officers, food and drug agency officers, media people.

Food security emerged as one of the central important issues in Indonesia’s agricultural development framework. In light of potential advances that biotechnology offers, the government of Indonesia identified biotechnology as the main tool to support national development, especially in industry and environment, agriculture and marine, medical and pharmaceutical fields. Research and development of agricultural biotechnology in Indonesia covered activities on crop improvement (marker assisted breeding and transgenic), food fermentation, tissue culture, application (micro propagation, protoplast fusion and secondary metabolite production) and biofertilizer /biopesticide.

In Indonesia, there are two types of biotechnology products consumed by the public- non-genetically engineered product that is mainly dominated by fermented food and the suspected genetically engineered products. Most of fermented food which originally produced traditionally by local farmers are unpacked products and are not regulated. One of the most important fermented foods is “Tempe” (fermented soybean). The fermented food and other soybean products (such as tofu) are the important protein sources for most of Indonesian people. Unfortunately, the country’s soybean production could not meet the national demand that Indonesia has to import soybean from other countries, mainly the US (80%). Since almost 70% of US soybean production is GM and the soybean is imported in bulk, it is being suspected that the imported soybeans available in the local market are genetically modified. However, until this time, Indonesia is yet to complete the development of food safety assessment regulations.

The two day activity which involved an open house and a national training workshop were conducted with the main goal of familiarizing the concerned stakeholders on the principles and procedures of food safety assessment and labeling. The workshop itself has the specific objectives of 1) reviewing scientific risk assessment; 2) introducing the technology on GMO detection to some stakeholders; 3) socializing the labeling procedure of GM food.

The open house was specifically conducted in conjunction with anniversary celebration of the Center. It enabled the public to have a rare insight as to the activities that scientists are doing in their secluded laboratories especially in the field of modern biotechnologies. Not only the laboratories were opened to the public but there were also displays and exhibits of all the activities of the different national research agencies especially in the field of crop production and development.

The following topics were presented and discussed during the workshop: Detection of GMO in Food by Prof. Antonius Suwanto of Bogor Agricultural University; Principles of Food Safety Assessment of GM Foods by Prof.Dedi Fardiaz of the National Agency for Drug and Food Control; Allergenicity Assessment on Food Derived from GM Crops by Prof. Maggy Thenawidjaja Suhartono; Nutritional and Safety Assessment of GM Foods by Prof. Deddy Muchtadi of Bogor Agricultural University; Status of GM Food Approval in SE-Asia/Asia/World by Dr. Flerida S. Cariño of the Universityty of the Philippines; and, Consumer Attitudes toward Agricultural Biotechnology by Dr. Dave Schmidt of the International Food Information Council and Foundation.

The workshop came out with the following conclusions and recommendations:


Conclusions:

  1. Key component of biosafety is risk assessment and management.
  2. Well trained and knowledgeable people are essential.
  3. Government and industry communications on food biotechnology must be consistent in order to earn consumer confidence.
  4. It is important to stress that food biotechnology also provides important benefits in addressing hunger and food security throughout the world.
  5. GM foods have now reached our doors and tables, with or without our approval.
  6. To date, the safety assessment has been based on the principle that GM Foods can be compared with traditional foods that have an established history for safe use.
  7. Safety assessment of GM Foods: to determine whether the GM Foods is considered to be safe for human consumption.
  8. Mandatory labeling of GM products is applied based on the threshold level (maximum level of GM products in foods, is 5%), set up by the government.
  9. Types of GMO assays: immunoassay, conventional PCR, Real-time PCR.
  10. Allergens are protein but not all proteins are allergen.
  11. Allergenic reactions depend on individual.

Recommendations:

  1. Food safety assessment and regulations on Foods derived from GM crops need to be established in Indonesia.
  2. National capacities in Indonesia for the development of human resources, research and technology, legislation, regulations, policies and programmes for food safety need to be strengthened.